Sustainable investing
January 16, 2023

Sustainable investing

January 16, 2023
Citi Private Bank
SUMMARY

Armed with the insight that we derive from our conversations with you and our analyses of your objectives and needs, we deliver portfolios and products customized to your worldview and financial objectives.


The pace of sustainable investing has rocketed over the past decade to record levels.

According to Bloomberg, $1 of every $3 invested will be invested sustainably, representing $53 trillion globally by 2025.1Sustainable investor motivations vary.

While some seek to minimize risk associated with issues such as climate change and/or the competitive returns sustainably operated companies stand to generate, others want to invest in innovations driving environmental and social progress across the globe. A growing amount of investors seek both.

Our personalized approach is rooted in our commitment to sustainability and extensive expertise in investment advisory, which we pair with a high level of service. Armed with the insight that we derive from our conversations with you and our analyses of your objectives and needs, we deliver portfolios and products customized to your worldview and financial objectives.

Drivers of sustainable investing

Investments that seek dual objectives

Sustainable investments seek varied financial and sustainability outcomes depending on their investment objectives and processes.

Sustainable investment has evolved from being a primarily exclusionary approach, to one focused on identifying companies that can effectively manage ESG risks and opportunities. The integration of ESG data can provide a more complete analysis of a company or security, potentially leading to strong risk-adjusted returns and subsequent value creation.

Sustainability serves both as a competitive advantage as well as a source of risk mitigation. In our view, companies that encompass ESG ideals or positive attributes are better positioned to deliver competitive risk-adjusted returns over time.

At some point in the not-too-distant future, a significant proportion of costs, or negative externalities, incurred outside one’s company, such as environmental damage, nature and biodiversity loss, or social upheaval, might be forced onto companies’ books. 

Along the same lines, companies that can point to operational benefits, or positive externalities, such as reduced pollution, safe and diverse work places through the supply chain, and transparent, ethical business practices, could stand to become even more appealing.  

Widespread adoption of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals

The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) serve as a roadmap for governments, philanthropists and investors to determine how and where to deploy their capital.

The SDGs help investors see where their capital is most needed and identify the interconnected, follow-on impact of each investment. It may also offer space for community services, such as childcare, that help remove the barriers to gainful employment faced by parents without resources (SDG 1, 5, and 10). 

Additionally, when less of a household’s budget must go toward housing, more resources are available for nutritional food and health services (SDG 11). 

 
 
 
 
 

Availability of solution-based innovations

The need for solutions that will enable the planet to become sustainable is generating investable innovations across technology, infrastructure, and science.

The urgency for solutions is magnified by secular trends that will present challenges beyond our current ones – chiefly that the global population will swell to 10 billion in 2050. 

Some of the innovations in the works today could well prove revolutionary. Many target the need for drinkable or agriculture-safe water, protection of the environment, renewable energy sources, and the provisioning of healthcare, nutrition, and education to those who lack it. 

Regulatory focus

Increasing regulatory focus on the impact of sustainability risks, such as those posed by climate change, are shifting how companies operate.

The Task Force on Climate Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) was established to improve and increase disclosures on governance of climate-related risks and opportunities. The “risk and opportunities” are important elements of the TCFD focus. New sustainability reporting requirements in various stock exchanges and the EU Sustainability-Related Disclosure Regulations (SFDR) enable investors to make more informed decisions about the companies with which they choose to own or engage with. For instance, they can help them better assess whether sectors and businesses are making sufficient preparations to transition to clean energy. Companies across many industries are adapting their operations or facing possible displacement.

Our sustainable investing platform and capabilities

Citi Global Wealth Investments offers discretionary portfolios, traditional investments, alternative investments, and tailored exposure to capital markets to enable clients to pursue their financial and sustainability objectives through multi-asset class portfolios or single strategy investments.

The term “Sustainable Investing” has, over the past two decades, evolved into a collective descriptor for a range of approaches. Each approach has its own financial and sustainability objectives and is available across traditional and alternative asset classes.

A single investment product can also combine multiple approaches to help you target exposure specific to what resonates with you.

  Socially responsible ESG integration Thematic Impact
Objective Reflect client’s values through company and/or sector exclusions Integrate ESG metrics to identify investments reflecting strong business practices and fewer ESG risks Access investments aligned to key sustainability themes (e.g., U.N. Sustainable Devlopment Goals with positive ESG outcomes) Invest in strategies designed to deliver a measurable and incremental impact
Financial objective Seek out competitive risk-adjusted returns within values constrained investments universe Seek out competitive risk-adjusted returns
Sustainability objective Values alignment Promote ESG principles Seek exposure to solution-based innovations Drive positive outcomes and create value for the investor and impacted stakeholders
Implementation Exclude investments based on products/services Select investments that reflect ESG objectives
      Select investments that offer products/services that align with an environmental, social or governance goal
      Invest in sustainable themes Invest in strategies with intentional and measurable impact
Example Avoid tobacco or arms manufacturers in investment portfolio Select a mutual 
fund that invests in companies with the best ESG footprints in their sectors and engages with portolio companies to drive improvement
Invest in a structured investment linked to the performance of a gender lens index Invest directly in a sustainable plastics company to drive a solution that requires additional capital to bring to fruition

Navigating sustainable investment options

There are multiple routes to sustainable investing. 

At Citi Global Wealth Investments, opportunities span discretionary managed portfolios and self-directed investments. The six steps below can help you navigate these options and determine which route to pursue.

 
Full disclosures below.

1. Review your financial objectives

Our investment process begins by gaining an understanding of your return expectations and risk tolerance, as well as your liquidity, geographic, and currency preferences.

We then customize a long-term plan – or strategic asset allocation – comprising sustainable and/or traditional investments per your preference, to pursue your goals. By assembling an appropriate mix of equities, fixed income, cash, and other asset classes, you can potentially enhance your core portfolio’s returns and help manage risk. 

2. Establish your sustainability objectives

Your sustainability objectives should reflect your worldview and values. The SDGs may help you narrow your objectives and prioritize them by their intended outcomes.

Important questions to ask yourself:

  • What outcomes are most important to you, and are they regional or global?
  • Are there specific thematic exposures  that you would like to explore, e.g. water, gender, education, or alternative energy?
  • What businesses would you be proud to support and why?
  • Are there sectors or companies that you would like to avoid?
  • To what degree should the impact of your investment dollars drive your decisions?

3. Evaluate your portfolio

The Global Investment Lab provides institutional-caliber analysis for your total wealth, including your holdings inside and outside Citi.

Our sophisticated proprietary modeling techniques help identify the intersection of your financial and sustainability objectives. 

These analyses incorporate sustainability alignment, portfolio risk assessment, and portfolio insights as well as action ideas across all asset classes.

This enables us to uncover risk exposures and potential opportunities in your portfolio and build a plan of action.

4. Select and fine tune

After evaluation, it’s time to select the appropriate investments. In keeping with our customized approach, investment selection incorporates the factors exclusive to your own situation.

For example, some investors may incur different tax obligations that may require a stepped or partial transition for certain investments. 

Here are a couple examples of how this may work:

A) An investor may be seeking to achieve a specific environmental goal such as financing renewable energy projects. This can be done through private investments that may require a long-term investment commitment or greater risk appetite. While this may be appropriate for some investors, others may seek out investments with shorter time horizons. These investors may choose to allocate their traditional fixed income holdings to green bonds with proceeds designated to financing a renewable energy transition.

B) An investor seeking to reduce the emissions associated with their portfolio may choose to avoid the fossil fuel sector. This could cause greater deviations from traditional benchmark performance due to the difference in sector composition. While this may be appropriate for a client who is not benchmark aware, an investor who is seeking performance in line with a traditional benchmark may instead choose a manager who owns fossil fuel companies with the lowest carbon emissions and actively engages with them to improve their environmental impact.

There are many ways to achieve your objectives. Please contact your advisor to help you set your objectives and select the most appropriate investments for you.

The following are sample allocations of a fully sustainable investment portfolio: 

 
 
 
This illustration is being shown as an example of reporting / analytical capabilities and does not reflect any actual client account, data or recommendation. Full disclosures below.
 

5. Timely and disciplined

Periodic assessments provide regular insight into the portfolio’s sustainability attributes against established objectives.

They can also evaluate the impact of incorporating sustainability risk into the overall portfolio. Impact and stewardship reporting from portfolio managers help gauge progress.

6. Philanthropic alignment

Investors also may apportion some of their capital to investments that place a higher value on social or environmental impact than on financial returns.

This often takes the form of philanthropic investments, revocable grants, donor-advised funds, and program-related investments.

Your questions

Sustainable investing is when investors seek varied financial and sustainability outcomes depending on their investment objectives and processes. It encompasses four main approaches, including Socially Responsible Investing (includes Ethical investing), ESG Integration, Thematic investing, and Impact investing.

Learn more about sustainable investing

There's a widespread perception that applying environmental, social, and governance criteria means sacrificing performance. We disagree.

Learn more

Sustainable investments are exposed to the same risks as other traditional investments. However, greater regulatory oversight and transparency is critical for investors to feel confident about sustainable investing. This includes understanding the ESG score behind an investment as it may not tell the full story; a deep fundamental analysis of a company or a portfolio manager’s investment processes is therefore essential.

Learn more about the risks of sustainable investments

In some jurisdictions, the term sustainable investment is used to describe very specific investments. For example, in the EU, the term sustainable investment has come to mean compliance with the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation and or alignment with the EU taxonomy which entails investing in companies which conduct specific economic activities that meet regulation defined environmental criteria.

Learn more

The four main approaches to sustainable investing are Socially Responsible Investing (encompasses Ethical investing), ESG Integration, Thematic Investing and Impact Investing. The last approach, Impact Investing, seeks to generate measurable impact in a particular environmental or social area.

Learn more
Sustainable investing

Our approach

The Private Bank offers managed opportunities, alternative investments and tailored exposure to capital markets. Sustainable investment portfolios deliver our best thinking in asset allocation, manager selection and portfolio construction utilizing the same investment management framework as our traditional portfolios.

Learn more
Contact us

To help put you in touch with the right Private Bank team, please answer the following questions.

1  Source: Bloomberg as of February 23, 2021. ESG assets may hit $53 trillion by 2025, a third of global AUM. 

Sustainable investment products are subject to availability. Certain sustainable investment opportunities may not be available in all regions or not available at all. ESG Integration uses Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) metrics to identify investments with potentially attractive risk and return characteristics. Investment mandates will incorporate ESG risks and opportunities that are considered material, integral drivers of investment decisions into their investment process. Managers of ESG integration strategies may directly engage with portfolio companies and / or use their proxy votes to help drive positive ESG outcomes. Thematic investments access exposure to investments aligned to sustainable themes such as climate change or access to healthcare. The SDGs outline possible applicable themes. Investments  seek alignment to sustainable themes through their business lines as demonstrated by their current and future revenue exposures. Impact investment selection is based on measurable impact in a particular environmental or social area. Investment mandates not only state intent, but also manage to a desired sustainable outcome by providing measurable metrics alongside a  potential financial return. To be considered impact, the outcome must be incremental meaning it would not have occurred had your capital not been allocated to the investment. 

Quantitative Research and Asset Allocation, Citi Investment Management as of 31 Oct 2021. Risk level 3 is designed for investors with a blended objective who require a mix of assets and seek a balance between investments that offer income and those positioned for a potentially higher return on investment. Risk level 3 may be appropriate for investors willing to subject their portfolio to additional risk for potential growth in addition to a level of income reflective of his/her stated risk tolerance. Please see CPB Quadrant publication for further allocation information. 
Investments mentioned in this document may not be suitable for all investors. Each investor should carefully view the risks associated with the investment and make a determination based upon the investor’s own particular circumstances, that the investment is consistent with the investor’s objective. ESG principles should not be the only consideration when making an investment decision. Selecting investments based on ESG principles will not guarantee positive future returns. There can be no assurance that any screening process will achieve its goals or that an investment will not incur losses.

Sustainable / Sustainability: In environmental science, the quality of not being harmful to the environment or depleting natural resources, and thereby supporting long-term ecological balance. Sustainability presumes that resources are finite and should be used conservatively and wisely with a view to long-term priorities and consequences of the ways in which resources are used. Within context of sustainable development, operating practices that meet the needs of present users without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs, particularly with regard to use and waste of natural resources. UNESCO assigns four dimensions to sustainable development - society, environment, culture and economy.

Sustainability Risk: Risk of an environmental, social or governance event or condition that, if it occurs, could cause an actual or a potential material negative impact on the value of an investment. The financial position of the investments in the portfolios managed by Citi Investment Management may deteriorate due to the environmental, or social, or governance risks these investments are exposed to, which in turn may impact the market value of investments made by Citi Investment Management.